Do I need a buffer?

suhr-bufferThere are trends and buzzwords in guitar gear, as there are anywhere else in society. A few years back, the trending buzzword was ”true bypass”, and the guitar discussion forums were flooded with threads on the subject (What is it? Is my pedal TB? What does it do?) and in addition to writing multiple answers in those types of threads, I also wrote a couple of articles on this site. In at least one of those articles, I mentioned the ”buffer amplifier” as an important part of a guitar signal chain.

In the present time (early 2014), the paradigm has shifted – now, the discussion forums are alight with questions about buffers, how they work and whether one should buy a dedicated buffer (illustrated here by the Suhr Buffer, although there are plenty of other similar units out there). This article aims to answer those questions, and possibly a few more. I’ll try to keep it as non-technical as possible – there are a couple of posters at The Gear Page who continue to impress me with their techie writing on the subject, so I thought I’d direct this to somewhat simpler minds (such as myself). But as always, let’s start at the beginning…

The signal chain

An electric guitar with passive pickups does not present the signal as a finished product at its output jack – everything from cables to the input impedance of the first active circuit (downstream from the guitar) becomes part of the circuit, affects the frequency response and resonant peak of the pickups, and therefore contributes to the tone. If you take an average electric guitar, a couple of true bypass pedals (turned off) and hook everything up with cables, the signal path the pickups ”see” looks something like this:

TB-signal

The parts and cables that make up (and influence) the tone are marked in red. The longer the total length of cable, the more treble will be rolled off (put simply – the actual tech is a bit more complicated). If you were to turn one of the pedals on, the cables after it would stop influencing the pickups (as that pedal then takes over the responsibility of driving the signal along towards the amp). So if you insert a buffer first in the chain, here’s what happens:

buffer-TB-chain

Basically, the guitar only ”sees” the first cable, while the remaining cables (marked green) are driven by the buffer’s output stage. This means that no matter what you turn on/off later in the chain, the guitar’s frequency response will stay consistent.

Do I need a dedicated buffer, then?

TuneMasterNot necessarily. If you have an all-true bypass pedalboard, you might. But most of us don’t, and you can often achieve the same effect as in the example above, by simply arranging your pedals to take advantage of their buffers.

For instance, any Boss/Ibanez type pedal (with electronic switching, as described in the ”FET switching” article) will be buffered, and can therefore serve this purpose. Or you can use a buffered tuner – having both functions in one box is a good idea, since both tend to live first (or very early) in the chain. I use a Korg DT-10 tuner on my board for this, and plenty of people swear by the Boss TU-2/3, which is also fine. However, most tuners these days seem to be true bypass. But one that goes against the grain is the T-Rex Tunemaster, which has a switch to select true or buffered bypass (along with a ”beef” pot that can boost the buffered signal, if you want). Also, the new Polytune 3 from TC Electronic is selectable true/buffered bypass. So it would seem the manufacturers are coming around 🙂

LehlesundaydriverBut that’s not to say dedicated buffers don’t have their merits. Not all buffers in pedals are created equal, and you may find one or two that has a negative impact on your tone. A dedicated guitar buffer is more likely to have a good impact, as it is specifically designed for this purpose. And if you’re thinking about adding a pedal just for buffering (rather than repositioning one that’s already there), dedicated buffers are often quite small and won’t eat up too much pedalboard real estate.

How does a buffer work?

Sometimes I see people claiming that a buffer can restore signal that has been lost, and however much I’d like it to be true, it isn’t. A buffer will not bring back treble that has been lost earlier in the chain – it can only preserve it from getting lost further down the chain.

At heart, a buffer is simply a 1:1 gain (same level at both input and output) amplifier stage. When placed early in the chain, it takes the place of whatever later input stage (in another pedal or the amp) later in the chain that the guitar pickups would otherwise be connecting to. Its input characteristics are designed to be good for the pickups to deal with, while its output characteristics are designed to drive long cable lengths and other obstacles, without loss of treble. Basically, it decouples the source (guitar pickups) from the load (the rest of the chain all the way to the amp). Or rather, it inserts its own load in place of the load the rest of the chain would otherwise pose.

This means that any active circuit conceptually functions as a buffer, so if you have a pedal you tend to leave on, it’ll do the job. It may not be ideal for the job, especially tonally, but that’s another matter.

What if I have more than one buffer?

Sometimes I see discussions on whether a dedicated buffer would be beneficial even when there are buffered pedals in the chain. The truth is that it probably wouldn’t help much. If you have a buffered tuner (such as a Boss TU-2) first in the chain, adding another buffer after it will not change the way the pickups interact with the chain (as the TU-2 is decoupling them from the rest of the chain). In those cases, you’d mostly be adding circuitry that doesn’t need to be there.

Sometimes it can be beneficial to have a second buffer at a later point in the chain, though. Some pedals will vary their tone depending on what follows them (you might find that your overdrive gets brighter when you turn the delay on, for instance), and having a buffer stage immediately after one of those pedals can help keep the tone consistent. But that’s a topic for another upcoming article 🙂